Skip to content

The Pros and Cons of S Corp Election

    Published June 27, 2023

    The decision to elect S corporation status is a significant one for any business. Understanding the pros and cons of S corporation election is crucial to making an informed decision. It is essential to take into account the unique circumstances and needs of your business. Keep in mind that what works best for one company may not necessarily be the best choice for another.

    Advantages of S Corp Election


    One of the primary advantages of an S corporation election is the elimination of double taxation. Unlike C corporations, which face taxation at both the corporate and shareholder levels, S corporations allow profits and losses to pass directly to shareholders, who then report this income on their personal tax returns. This can lead to substantial tax savings for the business and its shareholders.


    Another advantage is the protection from liability. Shareholders of an S Corporation enjoy limited liability protection, with  their personal assets protected from the corporation’s debts and liabilities. This benefit provides a safety net for shareholders, allowing them to invest in the business with less personal risk.


    It is worth noting that S Corporations often have more credibility with potential investors and clients compared to sole proprietorships or LLCs. This increased credibility can open up new business opportunities and contribute to the company’s overall growth. With the ability to have up to 100 shareholders, S Corporations can attract a wider range of investors, potentially leading to increased capital for the business.

    Disadvantages of S Corp Election

    Shareholder Restrictions

    One of the main drawbacks is the restrictions on shareholders. S Corporations can only have one class of stock and are limited to 100 shareholders. Additionally, shareholders cannot be non-American residents, partnerships, or other corporations. These restrictions can limit the corporation’s flexibility and potential for growth.

    Salary Requirements

    Another disadvantage is the salary requirements. Shareholders who are also employees must receive reasonable compensation, which is subject to payroll taxes. If the IRS deems the compensation unreasonably low, the corporation may face penalties.

    Administrative Requirements

    On top of that, S Corporations have more stringent reporting and management requirements compared to other business structures. They are required to adopt bylaws, issue stock, hold regular meetings, and record meeting minutes. These additional administrative responsibilities can be burdensome for small businesses.

    Take the Next Step with JTC CPAs

    While the decision to elect S Corporation status involves careful consideration of both the advantages and disadvantages, it’s crucial not to navigate these waters alone. Seek the guidance of a professional who understands the complexities of business taxation. With our growing firm of licensed accountants at JTC CPAs, we are ready to help you make an informed decision that suits your unique business situation. Call us to explore the benefits and challenges of S corporation election for your company.


    Contributor: Caleb Sapp